Saturday 22 November 2008

Why did Mrs. Luella Bates Washington Jones act kindly toward Roger even though he tried to steal her purse?

's short
story "Thank You, Ma'am" opens on a dark street around 11:00pm. A young boy sneaks up
on an old lady and tries to grab her purse, but he accidentally breaks the strap and falls over
on his back.

When the lady orders the boy to pick up the purse and hand it
back to her, and especially when she says "Now ain't you ashamed of yourself?",
readers might guess that the woman will march the boy straight to his own parents to inform them
about what happened and see that the boy is properly punished.

Yet that isn't
what happens.

With determination and physical strength, she takes him to her
own home--to wash his face, because no one is at the boy's home to do this for him. (We could
definitely interpret the face-washing as a powerful symbol: Mrs. Jones is cleansing his
soul.)

She learns his name (Roger) and cooks him a meal. (Again, check out
that awesome symbolism! Eating together is a powerful symbol of union. It's a hint that the
people who are sharing the meal also have something important in common.)

She
finds out why he was trying to steal the purse: he needed money for shoes; she gives it to him.
Then she sends him on his way.

The question is, why is she so kind to
him? 

Let's look at what she says to him before the meal: "I were young
once and I wanted things I could not get." Mrs. Jones sympathizes with Roger
because she, too, used to be young and in need, and so she shows him
kindness.

She also says, "I have done things, too, which
I would not tell you, son." She means that she's also done things she's not proud of, but
she doesn't say what, whether it was stealing, lying, or something worse. Again,
she sees that her past mistakes and Roger's recent one are similar, and that
sympathy inspires her to treat Roger with kindness and set him on the path to better
behavior.

Here's the clincher! "Everybody's got something
in common," Mrs. Jones says. That's the point of the story, and why she shows kindness to a
boy who tried to steal from her.

No comments:

Post a Comment

To what degree were the U.S., Great Britain, Germany, the USSR, and Japan successful in regards to their efforts in economic mobilization during the...

This is an enormous question that can't really be answered fully in this small space. But a few generalizations can be made. Bo...