Thursday 15 September 2011

Can anyone give me a brief summary of "The Worship of the Wealthy" by G.K. Chesterton?

In "The
Worship of the Wealthy," Chesterton criticizes the way very wealthy people are written
about in the popular press. He begins the essay by contrasting the way wealthy and powerful
people were written about in the past to the way they are presented in Chesterton's time. In the
past, he says, writers knew the wealthy were ordinary. As a result they simply went straight for
over-the-top, vastly exaggerated praise. They might, for example, compare a king to a sun at
noonday or say with his single sword he had conquered the world. The "safety" of this
was that it was so artificial it bore no relation to the real person.


Chesterton says, in contrast, that the way we praise the wealthy now is much more
"poisonous." This happens in several ways. First, ordinary traits or hobbies, such as
hating doctors or liking cats, are treated as if they are extraordinary. Because a person is
wealthy, boring and mundane things about the rich man are treated as if they are stunning and
special.

Second, even if the person is stupid, he will be treated as if he
were intelligent, his very dull and ordinary thought framed as if he had read and rejected
sophisticated philosophy.

Third, his lavish way of life will be treated as if
it is "modest" and "simple" and "quiet." This is especially
annoying when the funerals of the rich are described as modest and simple, when they include
lavish flowers, for example, and are attended by all the most important people. Chesterton mocks
this, asking: are they simple because there was no human sacrifice on the grave?


In sum, Chesterton argues that if we are going to lie about the rich, we should do it
in the old-fashioned way by out-and-out exaggeration, not by pretending their ordinary traits
are extraordinary or by declaring their lavish lifestyles are modest and
simple.

No comments:

Post a Comment

To what degree were the U.S., Great Britain, Germany, the USSR, and Japan successful in regards to their efforts in economic mobilization during the...

This is an enormous question that can't really be answered fully in this small space. But a few generalizations can be made. Bo...