Wednesday 30 November 2011

I'm well aware of Truman's misconception between appearance and reality in The Truman Show, but how does this relate to real life in today's society?

One of the
standout quotes from The Truman Show is, "We accept the reality of the world with which we
are presented." As Truman struggles to discover the true nature of his reality, he is
attempting to understand if there is more to the world around him. This argument goes back at
least as far as Plato's " of the Cave." In this argument, Plato supposes that we are
like prisoners in a cave. We are chained so that we can not turn and look behind ourselves. We
can only see the wall of the cave. Behind us, there is a fire and figures casting shadows, via
that fire, on the wall. Beyond that, outside the cave, is where the real Truth lies. Therefore,
according to Plato, we are thrice removed from Absolute Truth. Ideal (outside the cave), Figures
and the fire, and thirdly, the shadows which we see.

That is the historical
beginning of such a philosophical argument. In terms of modern society and how Truman's struggle
may apply, consider that first quote. What is it about society that we passively accept? Then
consider which of those things have been culturally constructed. They may have been so
constructed because governing people, political agendas, religious beliefs, etc.


Truman was born into his fake world. At some point he realized he was playing a role.
If he were to ignore playing that role, he could conceivably be someone/somewhere else. Truman's
world is made up. But the outside (our) world is somewhat similarly made by us. We may choose to
play roles society expects of us or we may explore other ways of being. So, it's not just that
the world we live in is an appearance in the sense that we make it up (in terms of
infrastructure, voting for politicians, working certain jobs, believing certain things, etc.)
Each of us also might ultimately face what Truman did. Why have I always accepted this role? Am
I missing something? Are the people in my life genuine or merely acting?


There are a lot of ways to interpret this film. Consider a very specific concept
whereby Truman comes to believe everyone around him has been acting. Only then does he consider
that he's been conditioned to behave in certain ways. His fear of the water is one such
condition. So, another way to go about this is to consider what you believe, are afraid of, etc.
And while those beliefs come from real experiences and reflect what you know about the world,
there is always the possibility that you can overcome a fear, change beliefs, and so
on.

 

 

No comments:

Post a Comment

To what degree were the U.S., Great Britain, Germany, the USSR, and Japan successful in regards to their efforts in economic mobilization during the...

This is an enormous question that can't really be answered fully in this small space. But a few generalizations can be made. Bo...