Saturday, 28 November 2009

In Chekhov's "The Bet," who in your opinion won the bet between the banker and the lawyer?

This is
an interesting question. There are several ways of looking at the outcome. It might be said that
neither of the men actually won or lost the bet, because the lawyer didn't collect the two
million rubles and the banker didn't lose the two million rubles. Morally speaking, however, it
would appear that the lawyer won the bet and  the lawyer decided to let the banker "off the
hook" by walking out the door five hours before the deadline.

The banker
seems to be acknowledging that he lost the bet by his thoughts and behavior on the night before
the term of imprisonment expired. He sneaks into the prisoner's room for the first time in
fifteen years with the intention of murdering him after keeping him in solitary confinement for
all that time. The banker himself would acknowledge that he had lost the bet, and the lawyer
would probably assert that he had won it, although he disdained to collect the money.


The bet itself is hard to understand. Initially the two men were arguing about the
relative cruelty of capital punishment versus life imprisonment. This is the pertinent
dialogue.

"The death sentence and the life sentence
are equally immoral, but if I had to choose between the death penalty and imprisonment for life,
I would certainly choose the second. To live anyhow is better than not at all."


A lively discussion arose. The banker, who was younger and more nervous in those days,
was suddenly carried away by excitement; he struck the table with his fist and shouted at the
young man.

"It's not true! I'll bet you two million you wouldn't stay in
solitary confinement for five years."

"If you mean that in
earnest," said the young man, "I'll take the bet, but I would stay not five but
fifteen years."

In the first place, the young lawyer
doesn't have anything like two million to put up. It isn't really a bet. The banker has nothing
to gain He probably regrets getting involved in such a contest as soon as he has committed
himself. He not only stands to lose a fortune, but he has to keep the lawyer in comfort for as
long as the young man chooses to stay. He provides his meals and even offers to serve him wine.
But how did the question of "life imprisonment" suddenly and inexplicably turn into
fifteen years of solitary confinement. Men serving life sentences are not sentenced to solitary
confinement too.

It was agreed that for fifteen years he
should not be free to cross the threshold of the lodge, to see human beings, to hear the human
voice, or to receive letters and newspapers. He was allowed to have a musical, instrument and
books, and was allowed to write letters, to drink wine, and to smoke....He might have anything
he wanted--books, music, wine, and so on--in any quantity he desired by writing an order, but
could only receive them through the window.

Chekhov had
to change the argument from capital punishment versus life imprisonment to capital punishment
versus fifteen years of solitary confinement. It is hard to detect the slight of hand by which
he does this, but he could hardly have a character serving a life sentence, because he would
have to die in prison in order to win. The bet is "wild and senseless" enough as it
is, but no one would bet he could spend life in a typical prison without the amenities the
banker was providing.

"" is not a typical Chekhov story. He does
not usually have surprise endings or even  resolutions. "The Lady with a Pet Dog" is
more "Chekhovian."

In what ways has Charlies relationship with Miss Kinnian changed? What are her fears about Charlies feelings for her? Do you think she has a...

In
by , the relationship between Miss Kinnian and Charlie begins to change.
Miss Kinnian had been Charlie's teacher at a school for the mentally disabled, but as he becomes
more and more intelligent, he begins to see her as a woman and a peer. He falls in love with
her. Miss Kinnian, though, is concerned that he will soon leave her behind intellectually, and
there is little hope for a long term commitment. She explains to Charlie the many levels of
intelligence and how he is moving up those levels at such a fast pace, nobody will be able to
keep up, including her. 

"'I can see only a little
bit of that, Charlie, and I won't go much higher than I am now, but you'll keep climbing up and
up, and see more and more, and each step will open new worlds that you never even knew existed.'
She frowned. 'I hope. . . I just hope to God--'" (Keyes 22).


Miss Kinnian is also worried about the possibility that Charlie's intelligence will
reverse itself, and of course, that is exactly what does happen. Charlie, at this point, does
not see it coming because Algernon has not yet begun to regress. Miss Kinnian's fears, of
course, are legitimate. It is very difficult to have a relationship with someone who functions
at a much higher level than you. It is almost as if their roles are reversed. Miss Kinnian, in a
way, becomes like the student that Charlie was in her classroom. 

Reflect on Chapter Seven, "As Long as Grass Grows of Water Runs," in Howard Zinn's A People's History of the United States.

Chapter
Seven of deals with the troubled relationship between the United States
and Native peoples. Its specific topic is, as Zinn writes, "Indian removal, as it has been
politely called." Analytically, Zinn wants to show how the removal of Native peoples east
of the Mississippi was essential to American expansion. Thus the growth of the United States and
the development of Jacksonian Democracy that accompanied it was contingent upon the oppression
of other peoples. This policy had the support of both ordinary whites and wealthy Southern
planters, both of whom benefited from it. The focal point of the chapter is the removal of the
Southeastern Indians, especially the Cherokee. These peoples, who had in many cases adopted some
cultural and political practices of white society, were nevertheless forced off of their lands
by Jackson and his followers, who Zinn portrays as relentless in their greed and racism. The
consequences for the Cherokee, in particular were tragic, as thousands perished on the
"Trail of Tears" to Indian Country in modern Oklahoma. Zinn cites estimates that over
4,000 died, and sums up Indian policy in the following way:


The Indian, not needed--indeed, sometimes an obstacle--could be dealt with by sheer
force, except that sometimes the language of paternalism preceded the burning of
villages.

 

Friday, 27 November 2009

Who is Emmanuel Goldstein in 1984?

Emmanuel
Goldstein is the figurehead of Big Brother's opposition and the Party's most prominent enemy.
Emmanuel Goldstein's image and identity are used to spread hysteria throughout Oceania's
dystopian society and conjure fear in the hearts of its citizens. During the daily Two Minutes
Hate ritual, Goldstein's image is projected on massive screens as he shouts anti-governmentat
the Party members, who become infuriated and vent their pent-up anger at the screen. In addition
to being used to spread hysteria, Emmanuel Goldstein also acts as a scapegoat. The Party blames
virtually everything on Goldstein's attempts to destroy their nation and uses his likeness to
divert the population's attention.

Goldstein is also the leader of the secret
organization dedicated to the demise of Big Brother known as the Brotherhood. Goldstein is not
only the leader of this group but is also the author of The Theory and Practice of
Oligarchical Collectivism
, which elaborates on the Party's methods of controlling the
population. Despite being such a prominent figure, Emmanuel Goldstein's existence is not
confirmed, and he could very well be a fabricated character created by the Party to help control
the population.

How many stronger is the gravitational force between Venus (`R_(Ven us)` =0.723 AU, `M_(Ven us)` =0.815 `M_(Earth)`) and the Sun when compared to the...

Borys Shumyatskiy

Hello!

You are right. By Newton's Law of universal gravitation the
gravitational force between two bodies is:

`G*(m_1*m_2)/r^2,`


where `G` is the gravitational constant, `m_1` and `m_2` are the masses of the bodies
and `r` is the distance between them. The value of G isn't necessary for this...


href="https://www.universetoday.com/22551/venus-compared-to-earth/">https://www.universetoday.com/22551/venus-compared-to-earth/]]>

How is the description of setting in paragraph 7 important to the development of the passages central theme of Americas changing history?

In
"," Irving is very careful to clearly indicate his opinions about the idea of change,
and of places that stay the same, in paragraph 7. He describes a peaceful place and then
elaborates that it specifically gets to be peaceful because it is unchanged by the forces of
industrialization or shifting populations. He even describes restlessness as a root cause of
these changes, which isn't a particularly forgiving take.

Irving goes on to
create an extendedout of this idea, likening Sleepy Hollow to the calm places around the edges
of running water, which swirl and bubble at their own rhythms, unaffected by the rushing
currents nearby. This paragraph clearly creates tension between the ideas of old ways and new
ways, a perfect frame for the theme of America's changing history.

Thursday, 26 November 2009

Explain the ways in which "Young Goodman Brown" relates to or deviates from Formalist critics' approach.

It is hard
to divorce "" from Hawthorne's influence regarding his criticism of Puritan culture.
Since Formalist criticism is not interested in biography or historical background, "Young
Goodman Brown" deviates from what the Formalist critic would call a strictly literary text.
Formalists were interested in the structure and form of the literary text. They were not
interested in the author's feelings, the reader's response or any historical, political
additions which refer to something outside of the text itself. "Young Goodman Brown"
also deviates from a strictly Formalist approach in that it has elements of Romanticism which
focus on the character's emotions and this indirectly and directly appeals to the feelings of
the reader: 

Had goodman Brown fallen asleep in the
forest, and only dreamed a wild dream of a witch-meeting? 

Be it so, if you
will. 

However, "Young Goodman Brown" does have
many literary qualities that make it ripe for a Formalist analysis. Formalists focus on the
artistic structure and form of literature: these elements are what separate literature from
other kinds of writing. Symbols, , plot, archetypes, and tropes are a few of these literary
elements. 

In the story, we don't know if Brown's journey is real or if it is
a dream. Whether dream or reality, Brown gets the message. But this ambiguity, or this , is a
literary quality which you would not find in other kinds of writing such as journalism.
"Young Goodman Brown" is also allegorical, another literary device in which characters
and events symbolize concepts (i.e. good and evil). 

Formalism was the
attempt to make the study of literature into a science. One could then use formalist analysis to
understand any work of literature from any period. Logically following, works from different
periods in history could have similar forms. "Young Goodman Brown" has elements of the
epic structure found in The Odyssey or Dante's
Inferno. A hero goes on a dangerous journey and comes back changed. The
hero character and the journey element of epic literature are literary devices, formal
techniques ofand structure. 

To what degree were the U.S., Great Britain, Germany, the USSR, and Japan successful in regards to their efforts in economic mobilization during the...

This is an enormous question that can't really be answered fully in this small space. But a few generalizations can be made. Bo...